On Tuesday, Claudine Gay, the President of Harvard, declared her resignation six months into her tenure amidst a tumultuous period of controversy within the university. In July 2023, Claudine Gay made history as Harvard’s first black president, leveraging her background in studying American political behaviour and serving in various administrative roles.
Her resignation, occurring within a month of testifying before Congress alongside leaders of prestigious universities on the issue of antisemitism after the Israel-Hamas war, marks a surprising development in her relatively short tenure.
The Announcement of Resignation
Gay expressed in a letter to the Harvard community that she would be stepping down as president with a heavy heart but a deep love for Harvard. She conveyed that, following consultations with members of the Corporation, it had become apparent that resigning was in the best interests of Harvard. This decision aimed to enable the community to navigate the extraordinary challenges of the moment with a focus on the institution rather than any individual.
Raging Controversies In College Campuses
Gay faced challenges from an ongoing plagiarism scandal and a problematic congressional hearing held last month. During the hearing, she, along with other university presidents, did not explicitly categorize calls for genocide against Jewish people as bullying and harassment on campus.
College campuses experienced heightened tensions following the October 7 terror attacks by Hamas on Israel, resulting in numerous protests and counterprotests, some escalating into violence. Mobile billboards near Harvard and Columbia displayed the faces and names of students allegedly associated with anti-Israel statements. The University of Pennsylvania reported violent antisemitic threats against faculty members to the FBI.
Allegations Of Plagiarism
Gay faced widespread criticism for alleged plagiarism, with instances of missing quotation marks and citations. Harvard disclosed that Gay intended to correct her 1997 PhD dissertation due to “inadequate citation,” following earlier corrections to scholarly articles from the 2000s. While the university deemed these corrections “regrettable,” they did not meet the threshold for punishable research misconduct.
Gay’s article incorporates several sentences from David T. Canon’s 1999 book, yet she neglects to employ quotation marks or provide proper citations in two specific passages. Furthermore, the resemblance between Canon’s endnotes and her footnotes is nearly verbatim.
Claudine Gay Made Corrections
Following allegations of plagiarism, Gay has sought corrections to two scholarly articles published in 2001 and 2017. In response to the accusations, Harvard initiated an independent review of Gay’s writings. Despite denying the allegations and expressing confidence in the integrity of her scholarship in a statement last week, the review, as announced by the Harvard Corporation on December 9, identified instances of inadequate citations. However, it concluded that there was “no violation of Harvard’s standards for research misconduct.”
In light of this, it was stated that Gay would request “four corrections in two articles to insert citations and quotation marks that were omitted from the original publications.”
According to a Harvard spokesperson, the university conducted a broader examination of Gay’s academic work, and the president intends to revise her 1997 PhD dissertation to address further instances of “inadequate citation.” In its evaluation of Gay’s work, Harvard refrained from explicitly using the term “plagiarism” and clarified that the identified shortcomings in her past work did not meet the criteria for a punishable offence under the university’s research misconduct rules. However, nothing seemed to have worked as she stepped down from her position.
What About The Interim President?
The Harvard Corporation declared in a letter on Tuesday that Alan M. Garber, presently holding the position of provost and chief academic officer at Harvard, will assume the role of interim president until a permanent successor is identified. The corporation expressed its fortune in having someone with Alan’s extensive experience, keen judgment, collaborative approach, and exceptional institutional knowledge to advance crucial priorities and steer the university through the interim period.
The Corporation stated that the initiation of the search for a new president would occur “in due course” without providing a specific timeline. In her letter, Gay mentioned her intention to transition back to a faculty position, emphasizing a return to the scholarly and teaching aspects that constitute the lifeblood of their academic pursuits.
Also read:
